Villas and Beach houses in Fire Island, NY

199 available villa offers

7 nights
2
1
  • airbnb
  • booking
  • hotelscom
  • vrbo
  • tripadvisor
  • expedia
  • tripcom
  • agoda
  • homestay
  • tuivillas
  • hostelworld
  • hotelopia
Fire Island, NY villas
Choose the perfect vacation accommodation
Price per night
Accommodation type
Rating

199 Villa rentals in Fire Island, NY

Best Fire Island, NY villas and beach houses with a pool

Among the 199 accommodations in Fire Island, NY, here are the 3 best villas and beach houses with a pool

House By The Sea @ Pines - Fire Island, NY
10 2 reviews

House By The Sea @ Pines

house, Fire Island
This three-bedroom, two-bathroom house on Fire Island offers comfortable family accommodation, ideally located for exploring the island's beaches and attractions; precise distances to specific landmarks require further clarification.
Sleeping six guests, the property includes a fully equipped kitchen with fridge, freezer, microwave, and dishwasher, plus air conditioning and a garden; further details regarding interior design and specific nearby activities are needed.
Guest House Retreat 
With Amazing Pool !!! - Fire Island, NY
9.9 39 reviews

Guest House Retreat With Amazing Pool !!!

house, North Bellport
This charming cottage is located in Bellport Village, a picturesque seaside town on Long Island's South Shore, just 145 kilometres from New York City. The property has received excellent ratings for location, cleanliness, and overall user experience.
The cottage has one bedroom and one bathroom, comfortably accommodating up to four guests. Enjoy the amenities including air conditioning, a swimming pool, a garden, and a kitchen with a fridge, perfect for a relaxing seaside getaway.
Stylish Private Mid Century Modern 3 Bedroom House - Fire Island, NY
10 23 reviews

Stylish Private Mid Century Modern 3 Bedroom House

house, Fire Island
This three-bedroom, two-bathroom house is located on Fire Island, a short walk from the beach and close to the town centre; the precise distance isn't specified.
The property, boasting a private pool, pool house, and extensive deck, comfortably sleeps six guests and features mid-century modern décor, air conditioning, and a fully equipped kitchen including a fridge, microwave, and dishwasher.

Best Fire Island, NY houses with a kitchen

Waterfront Designer Retreat! Stunning Sunsets! Less Than 5 Minutes To The Beach! - Fire Island, NY
8.5 4 reviews

Waterfront Designer Retreat! Stunning Sunsets! Less Than 5 Minutes To The Beach!

house, Shirley
This Shirley waterfront property, a short 5-minute drive from the beach and 27 km from Long Island MacArthur Airport, offers stunning sunset views.
The 116 square metre house boasts three bedrooms, one bathroom, sleeps nine guests, and includes a fully equipped kitchen, air conditioning, private parking, and complimentary Wi-Fi.
Bellport Captain's Carriage House (2 Floors) - Fire Island, NY
9.8 8 reviews

Bellport Captain's Carriage House (2 Floors)

house, Bellport
This private, secluded guest cottage, dating from 1876, is situated behind hedges and a gated entrance in Bellport Village, just a 5-minute walk from Bellport Marina and its ferry to Ho-Hum Beach, placing it within 30-40 kilometres of the North Fork Wine Country, the Hamptons and Fire Island.
This one-bedroom, one-bathroom cottage accommodates two guests and offers a full kitchen, WiFi, a Smart TV, a garden-view desk, a private outdoor shower, and seasonal shared access to the main estate's pool, with a private outdoor grilling and dining area available.
Great South Bay Cottage - Fire Island, NY
9.9 232 reviews

Great South Bay Cottage

house, Sayville
This charming cottage in Sayville is ideally situated for exploring the South Shore, with easy access to both the bay and ferries to the ocean. It's also a short train ride to New York City and the Hamptons, making it a convenient base for exploring the region. The cottage has received excellent ratings for its location, cleanliness, and overall experience.
The cottage is a comfortable and well-equipped property with a loft bedroom, a full kitchen, a dining area, and a den with a pull-out couch, comfortably sleeping up to four guests. The cottage comes with modern amenities like a flat-screen TV with Fire TV and Roku, as well as a COVID-conscious cleaning regime, ensuring a safe and enjoyable stay.
Sundown Escape Near Southshore University Hospital - Fire Island, NY
No reviews

Sundown Escape Near Southshore University Hospital

house, Islip
This accommodation is situated in Bay Shore, Islip, offering close proximity to SouthShore University Hospital and within 32 kilometres of Nassau Veterans Memorial Coliseum and 35 kilometres of Jones Beach.
This compact 46 square metre property provides air conditioning, complimentary WiFi, and a kitchenette equipped with a microwave and toaster, accommodating up to three guests with a private garden and parking.

Frequently Asked Questions about villa rentals in Fire Island, NY

Popular destinations

Best Fire Island, NY houses with air conditioning

Cayuga Street Sunshine Retreat - Fire Island, NY
9.4 23 reviews

Cayuga Street Sunshine Retreat

house, Fire Island
The Cayuga Street Sunshine Retreat is situated in Ocean Bay Park, Fire Island, just a 6.4 kilometre walk from Ocean Beach and 32 kilometres from Jones Beach.
This spacious five-bedroom house, measuring 445 square metres, offers a fully equipped kitchen, a private garden and a swimming pool, making it ideal for families or groups seeking a relaxing retreat.
Cabaña Entre Los áRboles - Fire Island, NY
10 60 reviews

Cabaña Entre Los áRboles

cabin, Brentwood
This Brentwood cottage is situated approximately 1.6km from Roberto Clemente Park and within a 16km radius of Heckscher State Park, Bay Shore's Main Street, the Long Island Rail Road to New York City, and the Fire Island Ferry.
The single-bedroom, single-bathroom lodge offers a spacious open-plan living area with kitchen (fridge, freezer, microwave), air conditioning, and a private garden with barbecue facilities; accommodating up to two guests.
Cozy Place - Fire Island, NY
9.8 56 reviews

Cozy Place

house, North Bay Shore
This private studio is located just 5 kilometres from the train station and a convenience store in North Bay Shore, offering easy access to local amenities and transportation.
The studio is ideal for two guests and features a private entrance, a fully equipped kitchenette, and a comfortable queen-size bed. Guests can enjoy a TV for entertainment, a private bathroom with amenities, and basic utensils and dishes for their convenience.
Island Retreat In Lonelyville - Fire Island, NY
10 1 review

Island Retreat In Lonelyville

cottage, Fire Island
This detached house on Fire Island offers excellent coastal access, being a short 300-metre walk from the Dunewood ferry dock and 600 metres from Fair Harbor.
This holiday home accommodates up to nine guests across four bedrooms, featuring air conditioning, internet, an outdoor shower, and ramped entry for ease of access.

Best Fire Island, NY villas and beach houses with jacuzzi

Classic Pines Bungalow With Every Amenity - Fire Island, NY
10 17 reviews

Classic Pines Bungalow With Every Amenity

bungalow, Fire Island
This Pines bungalow in Fire Island offers a prime location, just a 0.16 km stroll from the ferry terminal, shops, restaurants, and the beach.
Sleeping up to six guests, this three-bedroom, two-bathroom house boasts a heated pool, hot tub, Sonos sound system, and a rooftop sun deck; the third bedroom is even equipped for remote working.
©2026 cozycozy.com