Vacation Rentals in Fire Island, NY

1176 available vacation rental offers

7 nights
2
1
  • airbnb
  • booking
  • makemytrip
  • oyo
  • yatra
  • goibibo
  • travelguru
  • cleartrip
  • vrbo
  • expedia
  • hotelscom
  • tripcom
  • agoda
Fire Island, NY vacation rentals
Choose the perfect holiday accommodation
Price per night
Accommodation type
Rating

1176 Vacation rentals and Airbnb in Fire Island, NY

Best family friendly Fire Island, NY vacation rentals

Among the 1176 accommodations in Fire Island, NY, here are the 4 best family friendly rentals

Fire Island Beach House Ocean Bay Park - Fire Island, NY
10 72 reviews

Fire Island Beach House Ocean Bay Park

apartment, Fire Island
This charming house is located just a kilometre from Ocean Beach, offering easy access to the beautiful Fire Island beaches, as well as the nearby Atlantique Beach and Sunken Forest. It has received excellent user ratings, making it a popular choice for travellers seeking a comfortable and convenient stay.
This spacious property can accommodate up to 10 guests, offering plenty of room for families and groups of friends. Enjoy the convenience of a fully equipped kitchen, a relaxing patio, and a range of amenities such as air conditioning, a washing machine, and barbecue grills.
Fire Island Beach House - Fire Island, NY
10 7 reviews

Fire Island Beach House

apartment, Fire Island
This charming island home is situated in Bay Shore, Fire Island, just a short distance from the Fire Island Lighthouse and Fire Island Lighthouse, offering a tranquil escape with easy access to local attractions. The property has received excellent ratings from previous guests, highlighting its comfortable and well-equipped nature.
The home boasts a unique upside-down design, with the living area and deck offering stunning views of the South Bay. Guests can enjoy a fully equipped kitchen, laundry facilities, air conditioning, satellite TV, internet access, an outdoor shower, and a gas BBQ grill, making it ideal for a relaxing and enjoyable stay.
Fully Modern 3 Bedroom 65"smart Tvs Cable Bluetooth Speakers Etc - Fire Island, NY
9.6 30 reviews

Fully Modern 3 Bedroom 65"smart Tvs Cable Bluetooth Speakers Etc

apartment, Islip
This Islip holiday home is situated within 3.2km of Cohalan Court Complex, the Alfonse M. D'Amato United States Courthouse, and Bethpage Ballpark, and within 4.8km of Bay Shore Mini Golf and Bayard Cutting Arboretum State Park.
This 151 square metre property offers four bedrooms, one bathroom, sleeps six guests, and boasts a swimming pool, terrace, garden, free Wi-Fi, and a fully equipped kitchen; nearby attractions include a water park and family-friendly activities.
Last Minute Deal 7-6 7-12 Ocean Beach Fi House Perfect Distance To Beach & Town - Fire Island, NY
9.8 52 reviews

Last Minute Deal 7-6 7-12 Ocean Beach Fi House Perfect Distance To Beach & Town

apartment, Fire Island
This Ocean Beach holiday home, north of Midway, offers easy access to Ocean Beach village, its amenities, and attractions such as the Fair Harbor Ferry Terminal and Bergen Point Golf Course.
Sleeping up to ten guests, this four-bedroom, two-bathroom property boasts a fully equipped kitchen, garden, spa, and Wi-Fi, along with bikes, and a large deck with an outdoor shower.

Best Fire Island, NY vacation rentals with a pool

Among the 1176 accommodations in Fire Island, NY, here are the 3 best rentals with a pool

Stunning Pines Icon - Fire Island, NY
10 4 reviews

Stunning Pines Icon

apartment, Fire Island
This three-bedroom, two-bathroom holiday home in the Pines district of Fire Island is a short walk from the beach and is historically significant as the filming location of 'Boys in the Sand'.
The property, comprising a main house and guest house, sleeps six guests and boasts an enormous heated swimming pool, fitness centre, and Wi-Fi; nearby amenities include the attractions of the Pines.
Cozy Family-friendly Beach Retreat With Pool - Fire Island, NY
10 5 reviews

Cozy Family-friendly Beach Retreat With Pool

apartment, Bellport
This spacious apartment is located in Bellport, just a short drive from Patchogue Theatre for the Performing Arts and William Floyd Estate, making it a great base for exploring the area's cultural attractions. It has received excellent user ratings, indicating a high level of satisfaction from previous guests.
The apartment offers 232 square metres of living space with 5 bedrooms and 4 bathrooms, comfortably accommodating up to 10 guests. It includes a range of amenities, such as a private pool, a hot tub, a home gym, and two dedicated workspaces, ensuring a comfortable and enjoyable stay.
Westhampton Beach Oceanfront, 4 Bedrooms, Pool. Super Clean. Relax And Chill. - Fire Island, NY
9.8 76 reviews

Westhampton Beach Oceanfront, 4 Bedrooms, Pool. Super Clean. Relax And Chill.

apartment, West Hampton Dunes
This West Hampton Dunes beachfront property offers direct beach access and is a short 0.8km stroll from Moriches Bay and the Hamptons beaches, lying within 1.6km of Cupsogue County Park and Cupsogue Beach.
This 232 square metre house boasts four bedrooms, three bathrooms, sleeping eight guests, and includes a private pool, fully equipped kitchen, free Wi-Fi, and concierge service.

Frequently asked questions about holiday rentals in Fire Island, NY

  • What should a first-time visitor not miss in Fire Island, NY?

    You've got to see the iconic Fire Island Lighthouse, it's a must-see! And don't miss the chance to walk the beautiful beaches, especially the one at Robert Moses State Park.
  • What are the best Airbnb and vacation rentals in Fire Island, NY?

    In-law Apt A Block Away From Patchogue Bay, Private Queen Bedrm - Events - Petpally - Ltr - Mtr - Str and Just A Cozy Stay are the most popular Airbnb and vacation rentals in Fire Island, NY among travelers.

  • Which neighborhood in Fire Island, NY should you consider for a vacation rental?

    It really depends on what you're looking for. If you want a lively atmosphere, Ocean Beach is great. For a quieter, more family-friendly vibe, try Ocean Bay Park.
  • What are the most popular Airbnbs in Fire Island, NY?

  • What are the top family-friendly attractions in Fire Island, NY?

    The Fire Island Lighthouse is a great family outing, and the beaches are perfect for kids. The Fire Island National Seashore is also a great place to explore with the family, with lots of walking trails and wildlife to see.
  • What are the best vacation rentals with a pool in Fire Island, NY?

  • When is the best time to book a vacation rental in Fire Island, NY?

    You'll want to book well in advance, especially if you're coming during peak season, which is generally from June to August. If you're looking for a more affordable trip, consider visiting during the shoulder season, in May or September.
  • What are the best rentals for families and kids in Fire Island, NY?

  • What events or festivals should visitors check out in and around Fire Island, NY?

    The Fire Island Lighthouse Festival in June is a great time to visit, and the Ocean Beach Music Festival in July is also a popular event. There are also lots of smaller events and festivals happening throughout the summer.
  • What are the best rentals or Airbnbs with a jacuzzi in Fire Island, NY?

  • What are the best budget-friendly activities in Fire Island, NY?

    Walking the beaches is always free, and there are lots of free activities at the Fire Island National Seashore, like birdwatching and nature walks. You can also pack a picnic and enjoy a meal on the beach.
  • What are the best restaurants with local dishes in Fire Island, NY?

    The Fire Island Pines has some great restaurants, like The Lobster Roll and The Sunken Forest. For a more casual meal, try the Ocean Beach Pizza Shop.
  • What are the best walking or cycling routes in Fire Island, NY?

    The Fire Island National Seashore has a great network of walking trails, and you can also cycle along the paved paths. The Ocean Beach to Ocean Bay Park path is a popular choice.
  • Are there pet-friendly attractions in Fire Island, NY?

    Many of the beaches are pet-friendly, especially during the off-season. You can also find some pet-friendly restaurants and shops in the villages.
  • What are the benefits of choosing a vacation rental in Fire Island, NY?

    Vacation rentals offer more space and privacy than a hotel room, and they can be a more affordable option, especially if you're travelling with a group. Many rentals also have access to amenities like a pool or hot tub.
  • What are the top sports attractions and facilities in Fire Island, NY?

    Fire Island is known for its beautiful beaches, which are perfect for swimming, sunbathing, and surfing. There are also several tennis courts and a few golf courses in the area.

Popular destinations

Best Fire Island, NY holiday rentals with a balcony

Davis Park Fire Island Retreat - Fire Island, NY
No reviews

Davis Park Fire Island Retreat

house, Fire Island
This spacious air-conditioned holiday home is located in a quiet district of Fire Island, offering garden views from its terrace and easy access to the beach, just 100 meters away.
This 158 square meter property accommodates up to 19 guests with 2 bedrooms, 3 bathrooms, a fully equipped kitchen, complimentary WiFi, a private terrace, and a balcony.
The Cool House Waterfront Oasis, 3 Bedrm 2 Bath - Fire Island, NY
9.8 119 reviews

The Cool House Waterfront Oasis, 3 Bedrm 2 Bath

apartment, Mastic Beach
This waterfront holiday home is situated in Mastic Beach, on Long Island’s south shore, just 1.6 kilometres from the Atlantic Ocean and a short drive from the Hamptons. The property has received excellent ratings from previous guests for its location, cleanliness, and overall experience.
The house has three bedrooms and two bathrooms, comfortably accommodating up to ten guests. The property is fully equipped with a range of amenities, including a kitchen, air conditioning, a jacuzzi, a terrace, a garden, a fitness centre, a tennis court, and parking. Guests can enjoy a variety of activities such as playing games in the game room, relaxing on the deck, or taking a dip in the ocean.
The President Mansion Luxurious 7br Family Retreat - Fire Island, NY
9.5 2 reviews

The President Mansion Luxurious 7br Family Retreat

house, West Bay Shore
The President's Mansion is situated in West Bay Shore, just 35 kilometres from the Nassau Veterans Memorial Coliseum and 40 kilometres from Jones Beach. This location offers easy access to the area's attractions and a peaceful setting for a relaxing holiday.
This seven-bedroom villa provides spacious accommodation for up to 57 guests, with a total floor area of 730 square metres. The property features a range of amenities, including a Jacuzzi, spa, garden, terrace, restaurant, and parking, as well as family-friendly features like a play area and a baby safety gate.
Game Room, Hot Tub! Family Getaway In Bayshore - Fire Island, NY
No reviews

Game Room, Hot Tub! Family Getaway In Bayshore

house, West Bay Shore
Coastal Bayshore Presidents Mansion is a detached house situated in West Bay Shore, offering proximity to Benjamin's Memorial Beach, 2.9 kilometres away, and Nassau Veterans Memorial Coliseum, 29 kilometres distant.
This expansive 743-square-metre property accommodates up to 55 guests across 7 bedrooms, featuring a kitchen with a fridge, microwave, and dishwasher, air conditioning, a Jacuzzi, spa, fitness centre, garden, and parking, with WiFi included.

Best Fire Island, NY holiday rentals with parking

Shore Studio - Fire Island, NY
8.0 4 reviews

Shore Studio

apartment, Brightwaters
This studio flat is located in Brightwaters, a short drive from Bayshore's Main Street, with easy access to ferry services, beaches, Fire Island, and entertainment venues.
This property offers accommodation for two guests with a kitchen, air conditioning, and one bathroom, and is situated within walking distance of bars, restaurants, and clubs, and a 10-minute drive from Tanger Outlets.
Luxurious, Pristine Apartment Near Country Club, Perfect For A Splendid Getaway! - Fire Island, NY
8.8 6 reviews

Luxurious, Pristine Apartment Near Country Club, Perfect For A Splendid Getaway!

apartment, Bohemia
This Bohemia apartment, in Suffolk County, Long Island, is situated 0.8km from Connetquot River State Park, 4.8km from the Bohemia Historical Society Museum, and 4km from Bayard Cutting Arboretum State Park, with Oakdale railway station a 20-minute walk away.
The self-catering flat offers one bedroom, one bathroom, sleeping two guests, and includes a microwave, stovetop, washing machine, Smart TV, air conditioning, and private garden parking; nearby activities include nature walks, historical exploration, and easy access to public transport.
A-frame Cabin With Private Beach & Epic Sunsets - Fire Island, NY
9.6 211 reviews

A-frame Cabin With Private Beach & Epic Sunsets

cabin, Shirley
This A-frame lodge is located in Shirley, a 1.5-hour drive from New York City, with direct access to a private beach on the Great South Bay. The cabin has received excellent ratings for its location, cleanliness, and overall experience.
The lodge has three bedrooms and two bathrooms, comfortably accommodating up to six guests. The property offers a range of modern amenities, including a fully equipped kitchen, a dedicated workspace, and access to a private beach with opportunities for swimming, kayaking, and fishing.
Central 2br Walk-up; Near Flights, Food, Ferries! - Fire Island, NY
10 3 reviews

Central 2br Walk-up; Near Flights, Food, Ferries!

apartment, Sayville
This Sayville flat is ideally situated for easy access to the airport, beaches, and the town centre, with Whole Foods just 5 minutes away.
This accommodation for up to five guests offers two bedrooms, one bathroom, a fully equipped kitchen, air conditioning, and shared garden access, with an option to rent an adjoining studio.
©2026 cozycozy.com